TV series
Showcasing the most compelling crimes of yesteryear, when secrets festered, passions ran wild and cops had nothing but shoe-leather and gut instinct to catch a killer. Fashions may change but murder never goes out of style.
Availability
A Crime to Remember premiered November 12, 2013. We don't have a confirmed streaming, rental or purchase option yet.
Showcasing the most compelling crimes of yesteryear, when secrets festered, passions ran wild and cops had nothing but shoe-leather and gut instinct to catch a killer. Fashions may change but murder never goes out of style.
Choose an episode, then use the watch options above for the show.
Episode 1
Gaffney, SC, 1968: When a local reporter receives a mysterious phone call from a murderer who threatens to kill again, Gaffney police must race against the clock to try to save the town’s teen girls.
Guest stars Michelle McNamara
Episode 2
New York, NY, 1973: When a twenty-eight year old schoolteacher for deaf children is murdered in NYC, detectives immerse themselves in the swinging world of 1970's nightlife, where club-goers and activists rub shoulders with wide-eyed career girls.
Directed by Nicholas McCarthyWritten by Chloë BoxerGuest stars Michelle McNamara
Episode 3
Chicago, IL, 1966: The crime of the century begins when a man knocks on the door of a dormitory of nursing students and murders all…but one, who will live to help police attempt to bring him to justice.
Directed by Nicholas McCarthyWritten by Nicholas McCarthyGuest stars Zach McNally
Episode 4
New York, NY, 1937: Easter Sunday turns deadly when a pin-up model and two others are discovered brutally murdered. Religion, art, and madness come together in this twisted tale of love and obsession.
Where to watch A Crime to Remember
Episode 5
Macon, GA, 1960: When wealthy Mary Burge is found strangled in her bed, detectives encounter a world of hooded Klan members and blue blood Yankees where the truth truly is stranger than fiction.
Guest stars Roy Shuler, Scott Watson
Episode 6
Bay Village, OH, 1954: When Marilyn Sheppard is found beaten to death in her bedroom, it will take more than thirty years to piece together the truth of what happened the night she died.
Guest stars Chase Anderson, Liz Logan
Episode 7
Los Angeles, CA, 1934: Eric Madison is found dead in a boarding house at the back of the Warner Brother’s lot. But in an age where propriety is paramount, will the punishment fit the crime?
Where to watch A Crime to Remember
Episode 8
Odessa, TX, 1961: Teenager Betty Williams isn't home. She’s not at school. Police are sure she is a runaway, until they uncover a shocking high school rumor that will change this small town forever.
Guest stars Michelle McNamara, Katrine Hoyt, Mark Ryan Anderson
Episode information updated Sep 21, 2026
Available now in United States
These shows are available now and closely match A Crime to Remember.
Betsey BrownGretchen Fritz (1 episode)
Henry GagliardiNeighbor kid
Michelle McNamaraHerself
Chase AndersonChip Sheppard
Katrine HoytMack's Mom
Nyahale AllieNarrator (voice)
Alyssa MarvinAmelia Snyder (12)
Investigation DiscoveryUnited States
