Review poster

TV series

Review

2014TV-143 seasons7.5 / 10

Life: it's literally all we have. But is it any good?

A review of a movie, or a restaurant, or a car—or whatever else that typically falls under a critic's domain—is all well and good, and can even be helpful at times. But how can one find out about myriad other experiences that are never tackled in reviews? Enter Forrest MacNeil, a critic who goes beyond overviews of life's more-common subjects—way beyond—to satisfy the curiosity of others: The adrenaline rush of stealing; the danger of drug addiction; the delight of sleeping with a celebrity. MacNeil tries anything suggested by viewers of his TV show, then presents a 1-to-5-star review. But his unwavering commitment to experiencing intense adventures means he must deal with the unintended consequences of such a goal.

Availability

Not streaming in United States

Review premiered March 6, 2014. We don't have a confirmed streaming, rental or purchase option yet.

Synopsis

A review of a movie, or a restaurant, or a car—or whatever else that typically falls under a critic's domain—is all well and good, and can even be helpful at times. But how can one find out about myriad other experiences that are never tackled in reviews? Enter Forrest MacNeil, a critic who goes beyond overviews of life's more-common subjects—way beyond—to satisfy the curiosity of others: The adrenaline rush of stealing; the danger of drug addiction; the delight of sleeping with a celebrity. MacNeil tries anything suggested by viewers of his TV show, then presents a 1-to-5-star review. But his unwavering commitment to experiencing intense adventures means he must deal with the unintended consequences of such a goal.

Season 1 episodes

Choose an episode, then use the watch options above for the show.

Episode 1

Stealing, Addiction, Prom

23m

Forrest is requested to review shoplifting, cocaine addiction, and going to the prom (although he is in his forties).

Episode credits

Guest stars Fred Willard, Casey Simpson

Where to watch Review

Episode 2

Sex Tape, Racist, Hunting

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including making a sex tape, being a racist, and hunting.

Episode credits

Guest stars Fred Willard

Where to watch Review

Episode 3

Pancakes, Divorce, Pancakes

23m10.0 / 10

Forrest hits rock bottom after divorcing Suzanne and forcing himself to eat an unhealthy number of pancakes.

Where to watch Review

Episode 4

Celebrity, Batman

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including sleeping with a celebrity and being Batman.

Episode credits

Guest stars Ashley French, Julie Brister, Andy Richter

Where to watch Review

Episode 5

Best Friend, Space

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including having a best friend and going to space.

Episode credits

Guest stars Fred Willard, Lance Bass

Where to watch Review

Episode 6

Road Rage, Orgy

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences that include road rage and going to an orgy.

Episode credits

Guest stars Jason Mantzoukas

Where to watch Review

Episode 7

Revenge, Getting Rich, Aching

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences that include revenge, getting rich quick, and being institutionalized.

Episode credits

Guest stars Mason Dye, Emo Philips

Where to watch Review

Episode 8

Marry, Run, Party

23m

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including getting married, running from the law, and being the life of the party.

Where to watch Review

Episode 9

Quitting, Last Day, Irish

23mfinale

Critic Forrest MacNeil reviews real-life experiences including quitting your job, Carpe Diem, and being Irish.

Where to watch Review

Episode information updated Jul 23, 2026

More about Review

Cast

Andy DalyForrest MacNeil
Megan StevensonA J Gibbs
Jessica St. ClairSuzanne MacNeil
James UrbaniakGrant Grunderschmidt
Tara KarsianLucille
H. Michael CronerJosh
Kaden GibsonEric MacNeil
Max GailForrest's Father

Credits

Created by
Andy Daly

Production details

Status
Ended
Series type
Scripted
Episodes
22
Original language
English

Networks & production

  • Comedy CentralUnited States
  • Abso Lutely ProductionsUnited States
  • Andrew Daly Productions
  • Comedy CentralUnited States

Themes

criticmockumentarytv host