Rutherford Falls poster

TV series

Rutherford Falls

20212 seasons6.5 / 10

The past keeps popping up.

A small town in upstate New York is turned upside down when local legend and town namesake, Nathan Rutherford fights the moving of a historical statue.

Streaming, rental and purchase options

Where to watch in United States

Checked Nov 9, 2026

Rutherford Falls is available to stream on Peacock and Peacock Premium in United States. You can also buy it from Amazon, Apple TV, and Fandango at Home. Use the direct links below to open the provider.

Availability and prices can change. Confirm the details on the streaming service before you subscribe, rent or buy.

Synopsis

A small town in upstate New York is turned upside down when local legend and town namesake, Nathan Rutherford fights the moving of a historical statue.

Season 1 episodes

Choose an episode, then use the watch options above for the show.

Episode 1

Pilot

30m7.5 / 10

Nathan Rutherford and his friend Reagan fight against the relocation of a historical statue.

Episode credits

Written by Michael Schur, Sierra Teller Ornelas, Ed HelmsGuest stars Beth Stelling, Dana L. Wilson, Benjamin Koldyke, Will McLaughlin, Julia Jones, Bobby Wilson, Mimi Gianopulos, Amy Heidt

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 2

Buckheart Lodge

30m8.0 / 10

Nathan seeks guidance from a professor. Reagan tries to win over members of their Tribal Council.

Episode credits

Guest stars Julia Jones, Bobby Wilson, Mimi Gianopulos, Monica Padman, Paul F. Tompkins, Geraldine Keams, Eric Ledgin, Jason Grasi

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 3

Aunt Ida's 90th Birthday

30m6.5 / 10

Nathan leaves Reagan in charge of the museum and heads out of town to reconnect with his family.

Episode credits

Guest stars Benjamin Koldyke, Camille Schurer, Rachel Rodier, Martin Sensmeier, Helen Slayton-Hughes, Ally Young Price, Corey Landis, Judy Kain

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 4

Terry Thomas

30m9.0 / 10

Terry reflects on his family and career during an interview with Josh.

Episode credits

Guest stars Kimberly Guerrero, Kiawentiio, Geraldine Keams, Larry Joe Campbell, Devery Jacobs, Cha-tah Ellem, Jackie Old Coyote, Elva Guerra

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 5

History Fair

30m8.0 / 10

Nathan and Reagan serve as judges in their town's annual History Fair.

Episode credits

Guest stars Beth Stelling, Jonathan Charles, Dana L. Wilson, Sheri Foster, Bill Glass, McKale Jude Bingham, Adam Farabee, Jon Ryckman

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 6

Negotiations

30m8.0 / 10

Nathan seeks allies to settle legal difficulties and Reagan solicits donations for her cultural center.

Episode credits

Guest stars Beth Stelling, Kiawentiio, Dana L. Wilson, Julia Jones, Bobby Wilson, Mimi Gianopulos, Rio Magdaleno, Devery Jacobs

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 7

Rutherford Inc.

30m7.5 / 10

Negotiations ramp up between Rutherford Inc. and the Minishonka Nation. Reagan makes a discovery.

Episode credits

Guest stars Dana L. Wilson, Mimi Gianopulos, Paul F. Tompkins, Jason Grasi, Devery Jacobs, Adam Farabee, Gary Farmer, Robert Curtis Brown

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 8

Skoden

30m8.0 / 10

Terry and Reagan attend a Native American gaming conference;. Nathan forms an unlikely alliance.

Episode credits

Guest stars Dana L. Wilson, Chevonne Hughes, Geraldine Keams, Adam Farabee, Wiley M. Pickett, David Bickford, Cinda Adams, Ryan Begay

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 9

Stoodis

30m8.0 / 10

Nathan and Reagan struggle to navigate changes in their communities, livelihoods and friendship.

Episode credits

Guest stars Dana L. Wilson, Benjamin Koldyke, Nancy Berggren

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode 10

D'Angelos

30m7.5 / 10finale

Nathan tries to process his family history as Reagan struggles to hire staff for her cultural center.

Episode credits

Guest stars Beth Stelling, Julia Jones, Bobby Wilson, Michael Canetty, Bianca Lopez, Dan Considine, Vic Stagliano, Mary Garripoli

Where to watch Rutherford Falls

Episode information updated Nov 20, 2026

More about Rutherford Falls

Cast

Ed HelmsNathan Rutherford
Jana SchmiedingReagan Wells
Michael GreyeyesTerry Tarbell
Jesse LeighBobbie Yang
Dustin MilliganJosh Cogan
Beth StellingMs. Fish
Kimberly GuerreroRenee
Kaniehtiio HornFeather Day

Credits

Created by
Michael Schur, Sierra Teller Ornelas, Ed Helms
Written by
Ed Helms, Michael Schur, Sierra Teller Ornelas, Tazbah Chavez

Production details

Status
Canceled
Series type
Scripted
Episodes
18
Original language
English

Networks & production

  • PeacockUnited States
  • FremulonUnited States
  • 3 Arts EntertainmentUnited States
  • Pacific Electric Picture Co.United States
  • Universal TelevisionUnited States

Themes

native americansmall townstatueupstate new york